the signature of Noah’s Flood is found. The timing of the event, the location and height of the last sill to be breached, and the pre-flood level of the lake, are all uncertain. The word ‘Cim’ (‘Kim’) or ‘Him’ means ‘winter’ or ‘cold’. a coastal marsh environment adjacent to a freshwater lake. Chepalyga A.L. They say the ‘myth’ originated from a real event (their Black Sea flood), but that it has been grossly distorted and exaggerated as it was relayed by word of mouth before eventually being written down. Ethnologie 1:3. the Bible. The Black Sea is fed by rivers as well as by some backflow of saltwater from the Aegean Sea. [20], which is the time of the local floods of the Black Sea. popular media? waterlogged wood, charcoal (possibly), and a shard of obsidian were also collected. Herodotus: History. contrary, the flood legends are corrupted recollections of the one-and-only world-wide Cahiers de Géographie du Québec, Volume 48, n o 135, décembre 2004, Pages 311-334. The present-day Bosporus is probably this widened river. The oldest cities on planet Earth were unearthed in Anatolia on the territory of Turkey - Chatal Huyuk and Gobekly Tepe. of the Black Sea, Check your email! Kuman M (2018) The Mystery of the Black Sea Floods Solved. Origin of Celts, Welsh, and the “Native” Americans, Health and Happiness Books, Bulgaria. Sea flood was not Noah’s Flood, because it did not cover the highest mountains. dates would agree with the biblical date. Neither did the local Black Sea flood drown the people in the area—they were did not destroy all the animals and birds as the Bible describes. to find alternative home. Nevertheless, Ryan and Pitman suggest that many of these displaced The entire concept of the flooding of the Black Sea, as the basis of the Genesis Flood story, provides an excellent example where “science” supersedes the facts of Scripture with the ideas of man. Actually, the tribes were Aryans mixed with descendants of Noah. Voilà, the Black Sea flood matches! Ceramic jars dating to the 9th to 11th centuries A.D. were found on the floor of the Black Sea along a possible trade route between … Sea. The modern history of the Balkans does not tell us much about the Thracians. catastrophe around 1650 BC at the close of the Ice match the tell-tale signature of the Flood described in the Bible. So, the claim by Pitman and Ryan to have found Noah’s Flood is wrong. can be explained with the migration of Noah’s people to Egypt. In: The Black Sea Flood question: changes in coastline, climate and human settlement. it sells lots of books. It is this catastrophe which triggered the great Indo-European migrations. The temperature increase started at higher temperature, but the maximum it reached is about 2°C higher than the temperature maximum following the Big Ice Age. Achetez neuf ou d'occasion The fully preserved dunes were a proof that the flood must have happened fast. area. By comparison, at the height of the last ice age, sea levels were more than 100 m (330 ft) lower than they are now. There is an enduring myth that pervades the majority of world culture known as the great flood deluge. The Black Sea, located in South-eastern Europe is famous for its concentrated salt level, but scientists are now claiming that it was once a freshwater lake before an enormous flood deluged it. However, the Greek historian Herodotus of the 5th century B.C. With a local flood there would have been no need to save the animals and birds as The geology of the Bosporus also conforms with this hypothesis. Then, the time period between the two sets of floods is 2,562 years. The permanent submerging of some 100,000 km2 of exposed continental shelf would Bactria: The history of forgotten empire. in the atmospheric ratio of 14C/12C following the Flood. very large, overwhelming some 100,000 km2 of land the size of Texas. prove that after the local Black Sea floods of 7,000 years ago, some flooded Brygs (Brits) fled from the Balkans all the way to the British Isles. The mystery of sun worshiping. This can be seen on the Dr. Ballard’s side-scan sonar image of the ancient shoreline of the Black Sea (Figure 2). According to Herodotus [9], North of the Black Sea lived the descendants of Javan, son of Japheth, son of Noah. The Ryan and Pitman tale begins with the idea of explaining away the mythological fable of the flood. Translated by Isaac Lyttlebury. They brought to Egypt their knowledge, wisdom, and developed agriculture [1], p. 196). Indian ancient texts claim that Aryans settled in the Pamir Mountains north of India around 5000 B.C. So, the signature of the Black Sea flood does not match the record in the Bible. They were just like the clay plates unearthed in Sumer and dated 3300 B.C., but they were 2,000 years older. Instead, in its place was a large lake surrounded by a fertile plain. Some world-wide flood. Altogether seven species of saltwater molluscs were identified and yielded 14C In addition, some sediment samples were dredged The • The predictions also consider a range of flood scenarios (timing and magnitude). Let's first look at the more popular hypothesis: the flooding of the Black Sea, also known as Noah's Flood Hypothesis. This probably caused the floods, which Ballard dated as about 7,000 years ago. The Black Sea findings of Prof. Ryan and Pitman in 1998 and the dated by Dr. Ballard piece of wood, retrieved from a flooded house on the bottom of the sea, stirred a lot of interest to the topic. Based on study of the glaciers we dated the Big Floods as 9,500 years ago, which agrees with Prof. Petko Dimitrov’s dating published in 1982 and Dr. Ballard’s dating of the first layer of shells in Figure 2. Citation: Accepted Date: Sep 04, 2018 / Archeological proofs that Noah’s flood was about 9,500 years ago. The Black Sea deluge is a hypothesized catastrophic rise in the level of the Black Sea circa 5600 BC due to waters from the Mediterranean Sea breaching a sill in the Bosporus Strait. Every day, more than 50 km3 of water they have needed boats at all? ice sheets had melted, thereby raising ocean levels and allowing the Mediterranean In 2003 and 2007, a more ancient catastrophic flood scenario was proposed by Andrei L. Chepalyga for the Late Quaternary sea level rise of the Black Sea. Look at the ups and downs in the temperature (Figure 1) found by study of the glaciers [3]. shelf edge. The corrected 14C 2009. The Bible does not say In the late 1990s, Columbia University geologists William Ryan and Walter Pitman proposed that a great flood in the Middle East resulted from rising water levels at the end of the last Ice Age about 7,000 years ago. Springer ISBN 1-4020-4774-6. When a flood occurs the farmers, which cultivate the land, with the help of local legal people sue the state for repayment, usually without Because the waters rose so slowly, Ryan and Pitman say the people would have had any sign of a flood (Gen. 6:13–14). global Flood described in the Bible, viz. indicate that probably the so-called Sumerians lived around the Black Sea in 5300 B.C. If 7,000 years ago is the dating of the second sets of floods, the Big Noah Flood must have taken place 2,562 years earlier or 9,562 years ago (when the huge ice caps of the Big Ice Age were melting) [6,7]. So their link with Noah’s Flood is totally arbitrary. Comments on hacks and hunters. The Black Sea flood was not Noah’s Flood, because it Details vary, but the basic plot is the same. Earth Observatory in New York, who have published evidence for a large local flooding Ark perished, and ‘only Noah was left and those with him on the ark’ William Ryan & Walter Pitman published evidence of a massive flooding of the Black Sea during the Neolithic, 7600 years ago. We review each of these issues, in turn. They need a flood, so offer theory. Ryan and Pitman, aware of this omission, I think the physical evidence discovered in the Black Sea makes it pretty clear that a lower-level lake and surrounding valley were inundated by water from the Med via the Bosporus. eroded bedrock. rising waters!16 But why would to 15,500 BP. Enslow Publishers, New Jersey, USA. The evidence is consistent with a local post-Flood Ancient history since Noah’s Flood-How modern science shapes it (1st edn), Health and Happiness Books, Bulgaria. They say that the Bible got it wrong. flood legends arose, especially those in places like America and Australia. C14 dating found that the flood was about 7,000 years ago. Des milliers de livres avec la livraison chez vous en 1 jour ou en magasin avec -5% de réduction . These extensive meltwater flooding events linked several la… The suddenness of the inundation (The name ‘Himalayas’ has the same origin and means ‘cold land’ [19]. The hypothesis for a Late Pleistocene Great Flood argues that brackish Neoeuxinian Lake, which occupied the Black Sea basin, was rapidly inundated by glacial meltwater overflow from the Caspian Sea via the Manych-Kerch Spillway shortly after the Late Glacial Maximum, about 17,000–14,000 BP. • The predictions also consider a range of flood scenarios (timing and magnitude). Not even the ‘known’ world was submerged because there was still plenty of dry land left to live on in the area. History of the Tatar People, Kazan, Russsia. know that the two scientists see no evidence for a world-wide deluge in line with Age. catastrophe at the end of the Ice Age around 1650 BC. Pockley, P., Noah had a great flood but where is his ark? entirely of bleached fragments of freshwater shells similar to species alive today plenty of warning. Actually, they were Aryans mixed with descendants of Noah. 2021 - Open Access Publisher. Bible. Several other aspects of the Black Sea flood event have also been sources of long-standing debate and controversy. But their claim to have found Noah’s Flood is wrong—nothing but wild, An abrupt drowning of the Black Sea shelf. They settled there only after they built canals between the rivers to irrigate their land and avoid floods [20]. The results of these studies can be found in a review article published by S. Bardertscher, D. Fleitmann, et al. In July 1999, Robert Ballard explored the coastal waters of the opposite side of From Pictish Chronicles we know that the Picts (Brits) were Aryan tribe and their kingship was inherited by maternal line [7]. All Rights Reserved. THE BLACK SEA, THE FLOOD AND THE ANCIENT MYTHS. The New Encyclopedia Britannica (11th edn), English Language Reference Press, USA. reported ‘shapes that are too large for a shipwreck and too regularly shaped People carry a rescued person from the scene after floods caused by heavy rain in the mountain town of Dereli in Giresun province, along Turkey's Black Sea coastline, Sunday, Aug. 23, 2020. The idea of Noah’s Flood Theory (Black Sea deluge theory) was developed by Bulgarian scientist Petko Dimitrov in his publication “The Flooded ancient coastlines in Black Sea”., ISSN: 2367-5721. Figure 4: The movement of the tribes after the local Black Sea Floods of 7,000 years ago. It confirmed that the bottom of the Black There is a good case 1998), proposed that the Black Sea flood could have cast such a long shadow over succeeding cultures that it inspired the deluge account in the Babylonian epic of Gilgamesh and, in turn, the story of Noah in the Book of Genesis. Dr. Ballard [2] dated with C 14 the older shells as 15,500 - 7,500 years ago, which agrees with our dating of Noah’s Flood based on study of the glaciers - 9,500 years ago (Figure 1). It also agrees with the article of Livio Giosan, F. Filip, and S. Constantinescu [24], which claim that the big flood must have happened in 7400 B.C. In the If the level of the Black Sea had risen rapidly and people were displaced in days [6,22]. This does not allow any life to thrive below 300 m. Since bacteria wouldn’t live in such toxic environment, both Turkish and Ballard’s teams [2] searched the bottom of the sea hoping to find fully preserved ancient wrecked ships and they did. We have supplied this link to an article on an external website in good faith. in the fresher parts of the Azov, Caspian and Aral Seas and in river mouths in the Now, in real life, claims need to be justified. Widely publicised claims have been made in the scientific and popular media that Shopov Y. Y., Т. Yalamov, P. Dimitrov, D. Dimitrov and B. Shkodrov (2009b) Initiation of the Migration of Vedic Aryans to India by a Catastrophic Flooding of the Black Sea by Mediterranean Sea during the Holocene." Ryan, W.B.F., Pitman, W.C., Major, C.O., Shimkus, K., Moskalenko, Do they see this as another opportunity to discredit the Bible? on underlying strata. The water near the surface is twice less salty and runs from the Black Sea to the Aegean, but below 50 feet salty water is running in the opposite direction from the Aegean and Mediterranean to the Black Sea [1]. These lakes were probably formed during the warming that caused the Big (Noah’s) Flood following the Big Ice Age, when the huge glaciers of the adjacent mountains Altai, Tibet, Tien Shan, and Pamir were melting. Springer. meant that dwellings would have been abandoned and significant populations needed Stretching between the Black Sea and the Caspian Sea. by local farmers ripping their post huts apart to build puny boats to escape the The discovery of a manmade structure at the bottom of the Black Sea off northern Turkey has lent powerful support to a controversial theory suggesting Noah's Flood really happened. One of the found ancient ships was so well preserved that it looked as a new ship just released from the dock. sea levels toward the end of the Ice Age. obviously have displaced the inhabitants of the area. The Black Sea hypothesis theory suggests that the flooding process was spectacular and dramatic; water flowing into the Black Sea was the equivalent of 200 times the flow of Niagara Falls! Meridiane, Bucarest, 1968. this site either. The Dardanelles is 55 m (180 ft) deep and the Bosporus is as shallow as 36 m (118 ft). As we shall see, glaciers’ study supported by historical and archeological evidence (§5 to §8) show that the flood of 7,000 years ago was not Noah’s Flood. Figure 3: The so-called Noah’s plate found by Prof. Petko Dimitrov. Bulgarian History 1762. A FREE downloadable study guide is available from creation.com/tga. Ostling, R.N., Time to relocate Noah’s Flood? some 7,000 years ago. shelf edge indicating a shoreline of an ancient lake.10. After a while, these mixed tribes split: in the Balkans remained the mixture that spoke the language of Noah’s people, while the speaking Aryan language Thracians moved to Asia Minor, founded the country of Phrygia, and built the city of Troy. A long time ago, whether your time frame is biblical or geological, the Black Sea was a large freshwater Black “Lake.”. By using the term ‘myth’ they can disregard all the details of the biblical account that do not fit their Black Sea claim. However, Paisiy Hilendarski, who first wrote in 1762 the history of the Bulgarians in the Balkans [14], and independently of him Spiridon Jeroschimonach [15] claim that descendants of Sam also lived in the Balkans and that the Bulgarians’ line of descent branches from Sam, son of Noah, as well. , simply displaced from the land. Who were the flooded tribes living around the Black Sea? or 9,500 years ago, this means Noah’s people probably built it immediately after the Big Flood. However, legends on the island of Samothrace in the Aegean Sea claimed that the Black Sea flooded the Aegean with fresh water. Archeological dating indicates that Chatal Huyuk was inhabited from mid-8000 B.C. It is a good flood to pick, because Ryan and Pitman immediately claimed that this was Noah’s flood. Stimulated by "Noah’s Flood Hypothesis" proposed by W. Ryan and W. Pitman in which a catastrophic inundation of the Pontic basin was linked to the biblical story, leading experts in Black Sea research (including oceanography, marine geology, paleoclimate, paleoenvironment, archaeology, and linguistic spread) provide overviews of their data and interpretations obtained through empirical … Loess is a fine-grained deposit that sits like a blanket does not make sense. On the contrary, the flood legends are … The black sea, the flood, and the ancient myths. The name of the British Isles, named after the Brits (Brygs) and their sudden advanced agriculture around 5000 B.C. the Bible records (Gen. 6:19–21). Study of the glaciers; Black sea floods; Dating Noah’s flood; Dating the local floods; Split into Cimmerians and Sumerians. long) that explore the biblical and scientific truths of the Bible’s opening chapters. In 1999, a lecture tour across Australia was sponsored by the Australian Geological Figure 1: The temperature variations in the last 10,000 years show one deep minimum. of Noah’s Flood in the Bible. that the biblical record is just a corrupted version of flood legends derived from to find building material such as mud bricks, provided these could have survived The lake gradually dried out and the monks scattered all over Asia. of years. They founded there the state of Sumer. described in the Bible, 140 m long, 23 m wide and 14 m high (Gen. 6:14–16).